Reviews and AI search: the UK and US legal rules
To get more reviews that AI search can read, ask every customer for an honest review, offer nothing in return, and never tell them what to write. In the UK, the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 bans fake reviews and reviews that hide an incentive. In the US, the Federal Trade Commission's review rule bans fake reviews and incentives tied to a particular sentiment. Google Maps bans those practices too. Reviews can help an assistant decide who to name, but nobody can switch a mention on. AI results vary.
This is a practical summary of the public rules, not legal advice. If you are unsure, read the sources linked below or get advice for your own situation.
Why do reviews show up in AI answers?
When I asked Claude nine buyer questions with web search on 12 November 2026, the cited pages included review sites and directories as well as business websites. In a separate published check on 16 October 2026, I asked Claude four patient questions about 13 private dental practices in England. Of the 52 answers, 29 quoted a star rating or a review count. That was one assistant and one set of questions, so treat it as a snapshot. It does show that review text and scores are among the facts an assistant repeats.
The work is to have genuine reviews that match real jobs, and to collect them in a way the law and Google allow.
What does UK law ban?
From 6 April 2025, paragraph 13 of Schedule 20 to the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 makes several review practices automatically unfair and illegal. It bans submitting, or commissioning someone else to submit or write, a fake consumer review, or a review that conceals the fact it has been incentivised. A fake review is one that purports to be, but is not, based on a genuine experience. "Commissioning" includes incentivising by any means.
The same paragraph bans publishing consumer reviews, or information derived from them, in a misleading way. The Act gives examples: publishing positive reviews while removing or withholding negative ones, giving greater prominence to positive reviews than to negative ones, or omitting that a reviewer was commissioned to write the review.
If you publish reviews, or review scores derived from them, you also have to take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent those banned reviews and that misleading information appearing, and to remove them if they do. The Competition and Markets Authority explains this in its fake reviews guidance (CMA208), and in a short overview of the banned practice. CMA208 notes that a fake review can be positive or negative.
If you only ask customers to leave a review on Google or another platform, and you do not publish reviews yourself, the "publisher" duties sit mainly with that platform. You are still responsible for what you submit or commission. Do not write reviews, pay for them, or offer a discount or other benefit that is hidden in the review.
What does the US FTC rule ban?
The FTC's Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, at 16 CFR Part 465, has been in force since 21 October 2024. It bans a business from writing, creating, selling, buying or spreading a consumer review or testimonial that materially misrepresents that the reviewer exists, that they used the business, or what their experience was.
Section 465.4 is easy to miss. It bans providing compensation or other incentives in exchange for, or conditioned on, a review that expresses a particular sentiment, whether positive or negative. Disclosure does not cure a review that was bought on the condition that it is positive.
The rule also restricts insider reviews, such as reviews by officers, managers, staff or their close relatives, where the relationship is not clearly disclosed. It bans review sites that look independent but are controlled by the business, and it bans suppressing negative reviews or using threats to get them taken down.
What does Google Maps allow and ban?
Google's tips on getting more reviews support asking customers to leave a review, including with a Google link or a QR code, and they support replying to reviews. They also say reviews and other contributions must reflect a genuine experience. Offering incentives, such as discounted goods or services, in exchange for posting a review, changing a review, or removing a negative review, is treated as fake and misleading content and is prohibited.
Google's Maps policies on incentivised or biased reviews and rating manipulation cover the same ground: no payment or other benefit for a review, and no pressuring customers for a particular rating or review. Asking only the customers who already said they were happy, sometimes called review gating, is a form of selective asking. Do not do it. Ask everyone who used you.
Google's prohibited content policy is the umbrella rule for user-generated content on Maps.
How should you ask for reviews?
Keep it simple and the same for every customer:
- After the job, send a short message with a direct review link, or show a QR code. Google documents how to create a review link or QR code.
- Ask for an honest review of their experience. Do not suggest a star rating, and do not give them wording to paste.
- Offer nothing in return. No discount, no prize draw, no complimentary service, no entry into a contest.
- Reply to reviews, including critical ones, in line with Google's advice. Do not ask the reviewer to take a negative review down in exchange for a fix.
- If you display reviews on your own website, display a fair mix, and do not hide the negative ones.
That method is allowed under the UK and US rules described above, and it is what Google asks for. It is also the only method I recommend in how to get your business recommended by ChatGPT.
What should you avoid?
Do not write reviews yourself, and do not ask staff, friends or family to post reviews that look like independent customer opinions. In the US, an insider review that omits a clear disclosure of the relationship can breach the FTC rule even when the experience was real.
Do not use a service that sells reviews, generates review text, or posts on your behalf. The UK Act also bans offering services to traders for submitting or commissioning banned reviews, or for publishing reviews in a misleading way.
Do not put only five-star quotes on your homepage if you are withholding the rest. That is an example of misleading publication in the UK Act.
Frequently asked questions
Can I offer a discount if the customer leaves a review?
No, not if the discount is tied to leaving a review, and especially not if it is tied to a positive one. In the UK, a review that hides an incentive is a banned practice. In the US, an incentive conditioned on a particular sentiment is banned. Google also prohibits incentives for posting, changing or removing reviews. The safe approach is to offer nothing.
Can I ask only the customers who were happy?
No. Asking only happy customers is selective and is not allowed under Google's review policies. The UK Act also treats publishing positive reviews while withholding negative ones as a misleading way to publish reviews. Ask every customer.
Do reviews guarantee that ChatGPT will name my business?
No. Reviews are one of the sources assistants read, but AI results vary between runs, apps and users. Some businesses with strong ratings are still not named for some questions.
Is this legal advice?
No. It summarises public rules and guidance as they stood when this was written. Read the DMCC Act provision, CMA208, the FTC rule and Google's policies, and get advice if your situation is unusual.
Want a check of who AI names, including from reviews?
A Who-Gets-Named Check asks the questions your customers ask and records who is named and which review sites or directories are cited. The method page explains how a mention is counted. For local and service businesses generally, start at local businesses. If you are comparing providers, read how to choose an AI visibility service. AI results vary.